A Conversation with Jessica Slice About Her Experience with PANS/PANDAS

Journalist and author Jessica Slice comes back to the show to share her family’s experience with PANS, or pediatric acute-onset neuropsychiatric syndrome, which began when her daughter experienced a sudden and severe change in behavior and functioning following a viral illness. Jessica recently shared her story in a viral article in New York Magazine, and today she takes us deep into what happened to her daughter, the medical dismissal her family encountered, and the long path toward getting a diagnosis and treatment. We also dig into why PANS and PANDAS remain controversial, what researchers believe may be happening in the brain, and what Jessica learned through both her family’s experience and her reporting. And importantly, we talk about what parents can do if their child experiences a sudden, dramatic onset of symptoms that they suspect could be PANS or PANDAS, including where to begin and how to advocate for care.

 

About Jessica Slice

Jessica SliceJessica Slice is a journalist, author, and podcaster. Her book, Unfit Parent: A Disabled Mother Challenges an Inaccessible World was one of NPR’s top books of 2025. She has been published in Modern Love, the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Wall Street Journal, the Atlantic, the Guardian, The Globe & Mail, LitHub, Alice Wong’s bestselling Disability Visibility, Slate, Glamour, Cosmopolitan, and more.She’s been featured in Vogue, The New Yorker, PBS, NPR, The Cut, the BBC, etc.

She is the co-author of Dateable: Swiping Right, Hooking Up, and Settling Down, This is How We Play, This is How We Talk, and the forthcoming We Belong which was co-authored with the late Judy Heumann. She lives in Toronto with her family.

 

Things you’ll learn from this episode

  • How Jessica’s daughter’s sudden, dramatic loss of functioning after a routine virus ultimately led to a PANS diagnosis
  • Why PANS symptoms can be mistaken for psychosis, autism-related behavior, or other mental health conditions, potentially delaying appropriate care
  • How PANS differs from PANDAS and why infections beyond strep may be associated with sudden-onset neuropsychiatric symptoms
  • What researchers are exploring about immune dysfunction, the blood-brain barrier, and the basal ganglia in understanding PANS
  • Why controversy, conflicting medical guidance, insurance barriers, and treatment costs can make accessing care extraordinarily difficult for families
  • How parents can advocate for evidence-based care, evaluate trustworthy medical information, and keep pushing when their child’s sudden changes aren’t adequately explained

 

Resources mentioned

 

Want to go deeper?

The Differently Wired Club is not your typical membership community.

There’s something here for everyone, whether you’re a sit back and absorb learner, a hands-on, connect and engage learner, and everything in between. Join the Differently Wired Club and get unstuck, ditch the overwhelm, and find confidence, connection, and JOY in parenting your differently wired child.

 

Learn more about the Differently Wired Club

Episode Transcript

Debbie:
Hey Jessica, welcome back to the podcast.

Jessica Slice:
I’m so happy to be here with you.

Debbie:
I was very much looking forward to this conversation. We have caught up recently. You have been on quite a journey since you were on the show a couple of years ago now to talk about your book about being a disabled parent and life threw a curveball for you and you’ve been kind of writing about it and researching it. So yeah, so I appreciate you being willing to join me to really just get into this whole conversation with us today.

Jessica Slice:
Thanks. I’m so excited to talk about it. And I think your community, I mean, I’m sure this impacts a lot of members of your community or there’s curiosity about PANS and PANDAS. So I’m excited to spend time with it.

Debbie:
Yeah, there’s a lot of curiosity. It’s definitely come up in my community a lot. And it was a community member who turned me on to your Substack where you’ve been writing about this. And then, you know, as we’re recording this recently, you had a really well reported piece come out in New York magazine’s The Cut, and we’ll have a link to that in the show notes page, which was such a compelling thing to read and such a generous gift, I think, to share your experience so vulnerably. And I know the reception has probably been kind of pretty intense or maybe bigger than you imagined it would be. Can we actually start there? Can we talk about maybe the lens through which we’re coming to this conversation? Like what has happened in the past year of your life?

Jessica Slice:
So I’ll use names that my daughter picked out for her and her brother. So these are not the real names, but Rose, my daughter is nine, and we have a two-year-old, Calvin. And a year ago, September 26, 2025, she got a virus and it was normal. You know, we tested for COVID, it was negative. It was really like, as kids’ viruses go, one of the least exciting ones we had experienced. Sore throat, some congestion, very low grade fever. We all caught it. But after she started developing some very strange symptoms and things that we hadn’t seen before. Her first ones were that her limbs were moving out of her control and sort of like, I don’t know, I’ve tried to find ways of describing it like Frankenstein’s monster or a zombie. It was like she was in bed and she would just sit up and all of her limbs were suddenly very stiff and sticking out front. We took her to the hospital. They said not to worry about it. And then a few days after that, she experienced this sudden change. And I think what, you know, maybe this community would care about, or what’s applicable here is that she is autistic. And so she is already, you know, she’s neurodivergent. She experiences a certain collection of manifestations of that. But a few days after she developed this just dramatic change. So she was on the way to school with my husband and the baby, and it was like her eyes, they turned almost like she couldn’t see us or see my husband, but also they were wild looking. It was wild but unseen. And she started to say these like very, very violent things, in kind of a strange voice, almost like a baby voice. And then she just, as soon as they got there, my husband, she kept trying to choke my husband, was like arching, couldn’t control her body. He managed to get her back home. And then from there, things just started getting worse and worse and worse. She lost the ability to wear clothes. Like if they touched her, she would scream like they were hurting her. She lost the ability to use the toilet and she’s been potty trained since just before three. So it’s, you know, been a long time. She stopped talking. Screaming in this way. And I think anyone who’s been around an autistic meltdown will recognize like a fraction of it. It was just kind of like a desperate scream, but it was worse than anything we had ever heard. I mean, it was truly the sound someone would make as if they were being burned alive. She was screaming like that constantly. And then trying to choke or hit or kick my husband. He was the one with her. So I was taking care of the baby and we were trying, my husband and I were trying to figure out what to do, but it was extremely hard to communicate and she wasn’t eating, and it was just like a complete loss of function. And when we took her to the hospital, they said that this was psychosis and probably related to her autism. And when we said, no, this isn’t what it looks like for her, no one believed us.

Debbie:
Wow. It’s just such an incredible story to hear. Like I’m sure everyone listening to this is imagining how scary that must have been and confusing. And you go to a hospital where you’re expecting to be helped and it sounds like you were just gaslit or dismissed about what was actually going on. So what were your next steps after that?

Jessica Slice:
Yeah, we thought she would get admitted and they said the only place they could admit her was the adult psychiatric unit and that she would have a roommate and that we couldn’t go with her. And so we said no. I mean, we obviously weren’t sending our eight year old into a psychiatric unit with a roommate without us. But it also meant she left the hospital and her diagnosis was autism and mom declined admission, which was really too bad. Because I declined admission. And then incredibly, I was on a group text, and one of my friends on the text is a surgeon, and she, you know, it’s been a long time since she was in medical school. She doesn’t treat kids, but this thing she learned very briefly during a pediatric clerkship in medical school popped into her head. And she texted and said, with the recent illness you all had, is there any thought this could be PANS? And that prompted me to look it up. And when I looked it up, I was just like, wait, this is identical. Like the symptoms were sudden onset, rage, developmental regression, urinary incontinence, involuntary muscle movement, inability to eat, inability to wear clothes. It was just like a list of her exact symptoms. And so then from there, I contacted our pediatrician and said, my gosh, I have some really good news. We figured it out. And he was like, that’s actually, he was like, that’s a contested illness. We aren’t even sure if it’s real. If it is, it’s extremely rare. Like that’s definitely not what’s happening. He or she needs a psychiatrist.

Debbie:
Wow. Had you heard of PANS before?

Jessica Slice:
No, I mean, there’s a podcaster and author I really like, Alison Raskin, and she had PANDAS as a kid. But I had not really internalized that or ever paid attention to what it was or what causes it. So looking back, I had heard the word PANDAS. And I’m happy to explain the distinction between them, but no, it was not in my mind. I had truly no idea that an illness could cause this kind of onset of symptoms.

Debbie:
I just interviewed someone about burnout in kids and we were also talking about how it’s just so misunderstood or not necessarily believed. Like there’s so many experiences that we in this space in this community have with our kids that are just not understood. And so we have to kind of turn into these, you know, these avid researchers, it has to become our deep area of interest and we have to fight for things and it’s exhausting. So when you weren’t given the support that you were hoping for from the pediatrician, once you were like, we know what it is, we have this, can you walk us through what your next steps were and how you kind of were able to get some support for your daughter?

Jessica Slice:
Yeah, I was able to get him to prescribe us a short course of antibiotics, which are the first line of treatment. So the PANS PANDAS Physician Network, which is a website I would recommend for reliable information, they have a flow chart for symptoms and treatment steps. And, you know, I knew she needed a course of azithromycin and I knew she needed an Advil type medication. And he agreed to prescribe it, well, maybe this was strep, we may as well do this and it will kind of be evidence that this isn’t the issue, you know, like an exclusionary medication. And so we had that and we had tried a few like psychotropic medications during this brief period, you know, mainly Ativan and it wasn’t touching it, but we started the azithromycin and within 24 hours she started to improve. And it was like the first, it went from screaming 16 hours a day and sleeping max one hour a night to sleeping probably five to six hours and screaming maybe eight hours a day. So it was still in crisis. But it was clear to us that there was something happening here. So then I just contacted moms on a Facebook group to see if there was another doctor who would prescribe additional azithromycin, or additional antibiotics, which was something I really didn’t want to do. I had already contacted the children’s hospital here. I contacted a futurologist. I talked to our pediatrician. We had been to the hospital three times and we weren’t able to get help. And it felt to me like my child may die. And I felt like I had to do whatever it took to get her this medication that was helping. So I found a nurse practitioner who for a fee would meet with me and prescribe a month of azithromycin. And it continued to like cause some improvement. And then I started contacting doctors in the US who specialize in PANS PANDAS to try to get a virtual consult. And I got in with one in Chicago. It was $750. You know, we paid out of pocket and he only took checks. And I was worried about sending a check from Canada. So my parents in the US mailed him a check so it would get there sooner so we could see him. And when we met and we walked through, you know, what had happened, he was like, this is textbook. I mean, this is, there is nothing about this that would make me question if this is a PANS PANDAS diagnosis. And he said she needed the azithromycin and then if she didn’t improve, IVIG and that he could order the IVIG to the hospital near him, but we’d have to get her to Chicago and then pay, you know, 15 to 20,000 out of pocket for one treatment. And honestly, at that point, because her life felt like it was on the line, the biggest hurdle in our minds was how would we get her on a plane to Chicago? I mean, we couldn’t get her into the next room. It just was impossible. She wasn’t wearing clothes. There was no way. So then we kept looking for doctors and that was months of trying to figure out how to get her care. And during that time I became really curious about why is there this illness that, you know, I had started to get to know who the researchers were. So why is there this illness that’s studied at these incredible institutions that has these treatment protocols that work, yet so many doctors won’t treat it, so many people won’t recognize its existence, it’s almost impossible to access care. Like I became sort of flummoxed by the difference between what we know about the illness and then what care families can access. And so while we were still really working on getting her care, I started reporting a story on it. And at that time it was with the New York Times. It ended up switching to New York magazine, but I started working on that piece. I’ll just skip ahead so we can move on from our story. We did eventually pay for her to get IVIG in New York. We drove across the border to Buffalo. And that was in December. So that was three months after onset, and she was still very, very, very ill at that time. And within a few days of that first IVIG treatment, we had a few weeks of 80% improvement. It was incredible. She asked me to style her hair, she put on a dress, she celebrated Christmas with the family, she started to be able to read again, she started to speak again. You know, she hadn’t really been able to speak. She let me hug her for the first time in months. I mean, it was a huge, huge improvement. And so that was December of 2025. And then that prompted me to start on the process of advocating for her to get more IVIG here in Canada because we couldn’t, it’s obviously unsustainable to go to the US monthly and pay. We can’t pay monthly for that. I mean, who can? And so she started monthly IVIG in Canada in April 2026. And so she’s now, tomorrow she’ll have her sixth monthly dose here in Canada.

Debbie:
Okay, wow. What an incredible journey you’ve been through and just harrowing. And I can only imagine the toll it took on you personally and like to have that kind of fear for your child’s life and you have a young child also that you’re caring for. So yeah, I can’t even fathom. Again, when I read your piece, I was so struck by it. And I guess, you know, is that what you experienced, and we could maybe talk about what you learned about, you said there’s PANS and PANDAS, those two things, but what you experienced, is that kind of a typical presentation for how PANS can present in kids?

Jessica Slice:
It’s on the more severe end, but it’s not unusual. I’ve talked to a lot of families who have had it this bad. There’s also kids who develop it suddenly like we did, but it’s more OCD specific, or more restrictive eating specific. And my daughter had both of those things, but her other symptoms were so severe it was kind of hard to see through to that. There’s also, you know, kids who have a more mild onset and can still attend school, but are having, you know, a lot of a hallmark of developing PANS and PANDAS is developing this urge to spit out your saliva, like fear of your own saliva. So they’ll start spitting a lot at school or collecting their spit in their mouth at school and spitting in the bathroom. But one of our scariest symptoms, maybe a week and a half, two weeks in, we got a referral to an outpatient psychiatrist. And it was awful. She just screamed the whole time. It was barely an appointment. I mean, it wasn’t. And then leaving the hospital, she tried to jump from the moving car. And I have since heard from hundreds, I mean, hundreds and hundreds of families whose kid around onset tried to jump from a moving car. And so that seems to be a real hallmark of the condition for a reason I don’t totally understand. And so I obviously consider that quite severe, but that can sometimes happen in kids who are also, you know, still able to speak or, you know, didn’t have the same quite loss of function that my daughter did.

Debbie:
Right. So would you talk about PANDAS and PANS, I see them always together. Usually it’s PANS slash PANDAS. Is it an acronym for something?

Jessica Slice:
Yeah, so PANS stands for Pediatric Acute Onset Neuropsychiatric Syndrome. And PANDAS is Pediatric Autoimmune Neuropsychiatric Disorders Associated with Strep. In the 90s, a doctor at the NIMH, so the National Institute of Health for Mental Illness, Dr. Sue Swedo wrote this sort of seminal paper on 50 cases of kids who develop strep and then develop sudden psychiatric changes after. And that was the identification and the naming of PANDAS. In the decade and a half after that, researchers there and at Stanford, Dartmouth and MassGen started to identify that other illnesses were causing the same syndrome. So they originally thought only strep could cause this, and that’s why it was PANDAS. And then they realized other things could, Epstein Barr, flu, COVID, Lyme, mycoplasma pneumonia causes it often. And my suspicion is that’s what we had. So they changed the definition and then changed the acronym to PANS. So PANS is now a larger umbrella under which PANDAS falls.

Debbie:
Okay, thank you. That’s super helpful. And the nineties was when this was first researched and became a known thing. So a lot of what you write about and what you uncovered in this piece is about the, I don’t know if legitimacy is the right word, but there’s definitely been a lot of pushback and division within the medical community about this as a diagnosis. So could you kind of talk us through what was maybe most surprising? Cause it would seem like, well, we know about this, right? So why isn’t it out there for everybody to get the support that they need?

Jessica Slice:
So what we know at this point is that the basal ganglia, which is a part of your brain that controls impulse control, some of your motor control and emotional regulation, it’s also, they’ve identified it, you know, in the past, this is undisputed, is sort of where Tourette’s and OCD live. Now a researcher would probably amend that and say it’s like also in other places. But maybe I’ll say from here on out, I will be explaining medical things in a way that I think people can best understand. And that I would assume if you had a PhD immunologist on, they could say it in a slightly more accurate way. But I do feel like I understand this. So the basal ganglia is kind of the home of these functions. And we have identified that PANS attacks the basal ganglia. And the way they know that is that they have done studies with slices of brains where they take blood from PANS people and it attacks the basal ganglia, it damages a part called the interneuron, which is a type of neuron in that part of the brain. There are also some researchers at Columbia who have identified the actual pathway for it, like a virus releases a certain kind of white blood cell. That white blood cell travels through the olfactory nerve. It compromises the integrity of the blood brain barrier. So in your brain, your circulatory system has a stronger barrier between it and the central nervous system. But that barrier is broken down by these certain white blood cells, and then certain proteins are released in the basal ganglia that damage the interneurons. So there’s actually a really good understanding of the mechanism. We also know that if you do a scan of a brain for someone when they’re in a PANS flare and then a scan after, the shape of the basal ganglia changes. But that scan, as far as I understand it, is not accurate for diagnosing because most kids don’t have a baseline scan of their basal ganglia. And if it’s not outside a normal range, what would that information give during a flare? So it’s kind of like a retrospective diagnostic tool. There are also certain circulatory antibodies that change. There are a few things that can show up during blood tests. My daughter’s blood tests have changed a lot with this, but essentially we have a very good understanding of the mechanism, better than we do for a lot of undisputed illnesses. The thing that really shocked me in my reporting is there’s been this cohort of neurologists who have been kind of anti PANS PANDAS from the beginning. And they are the source of the vast majority of papers that dispute PANS and PANDAS. Like it’s this same group of people, like five or six guys who just keep writing these papers over and over again. But they’ve been, their work has been effective. They, for some reason, and this is something I really want to understand, and maybe someone will explain it to me at some point. But if you say that a person’s work is controversial, and maybe particularly if that person is a woman, like Dr. Swedo is, that work becomes controversial. And then the proof needed to re-legitimize the work is greater than just the burden of information needed. And so, I spoke to a Harvard researcher who said, now you have to force religious conversions. It’s not just a weighing of the evidence. And so Dr. Swedo published this work, this group of people, and they all are neurologists who study Tourette’s and OCD, that are illnesses that are often probably misdiagnosed when it’s actually PANS and PANDAS. They started publishing these papers. They also started saying some inflammatory things about her. They publicly called her a quack. They compared her to like this doctor who started removing uteruses for no reason. They just kind of like publicly discredited her. And then that effort has had these tentacles that have lasted until now. So when I interview doctors who are skeptical about PANS and PANDAS, they always recite one of these few neurologists. It’s just this weird circular world. And I want to understand more about why that’s so effective. And it makes me think about other things like the way HRT for women going through perimenopause, how that was like one flawed study made it so that was considered dangerous and like information to the contrary has had trouble breaking through. Like what is it about something negative that can influence a whole society and then it’s so hard to get it back.

Debbie:
Yeah, so as you were talking about that, I think I wrote down why, like what is in it for people to hide this? Were you able to discover any kind of reasons? Is it hoarding of resources? Is it, yeah, I’m just curious, you know, who benefits from this not being something that is more widely shared and considered a valid thing.

Jessica Slice:
Well, in 2010, Sue Swedo said to Scientific American that she believes up to 25% of people diagnosed with tics, Tourette’s, and OCD may have PANS and PANDAS. And it was after that that the rate of papers discrediting Sue Swedo picked up. And the people doing that discrediting all are people who treat Tourette’s and OCD. So I do not know the motivation, but I do know that she was making statements that could in theory threaten research funding, threaten their patient population, threaten a position within a field. I don’t know. And I don’t know enough about how research and medicine works to know, could that really be so highly motivating? But I do know that timing exists.

Debbie:
Does that carry over into where we are now? I’m just wondering, you know, in terms of finding doctors to take this seriously and to be willing to provide prescriptions for the medication that we know can be effective. Is it something that people don’t want to be associated with? Can you talk about that dynamic?

Jessica Slice:
Well, so the AAP, the American Academy of Pediatrics, brought a committee together in 2024 to write, you know, like their clinical report on PANS PANDAS. What’s so remarkable about that paper is for the first time since 1948, they issued a clinical report with no named authors. I have an idea about authorship. What I do know is that I have interviewed nearly at this point every major PANS researcher, and none of them were on the committee. It’s very unusual for the AAP to put together a committee and not include the people who research the illness. It’s generally that the experts in a field write the report on the field. So they didn’t disclose, they didn’t include the experts. The report frames PANS PANDAS as an illness they say is likely valid, which is not language they use in other reports. And their treatment proposal is SSRIs and CBT. There have been no studies on SSRIs for PANS PANDAS. The doctors I interviewed say they aren’t effective. They can eventually be effective, but until the immune response is impacted, it’s not an effective treatment. CBT, there’s been one study, it had seven people and no control group. The patients who got CBT did not report improvement in symptoms. The people who gave them CBT said there were improvements. But the AAP presents those two things as the most effective treatment for PANS and PANDAS. I do not know why the report is the way it is. I interviewed the AAP when writing my piece. I interviewed the chief medical officer. We had a long conversation. She said she knows that PANS and PANDAS are very real. And I said, would you update the report to say that? And she said, we don’t see a reason to at the time. We stand behind it as written. I mentioned that there are treatments that have evidence behind them that aren’t included in the report. And they said they need more evidence. There’s a real disparity in the amount of evidence for the treatments they suggest versus the ones that work. But the AAP report since it came out in early 2025 has been quoted by many insurance companies. I’ve been reading the letters to deny access to IVIG, the treatment that helped my daughter so much. In fact, an article came out this year that said 58% of people have to sell major assets for their kids with PANS to access IVIG. 82% of claims for IVIG are denied by insurance companies right now. It is very, very bad and it’s life threatening. 13% of kids under the age of seven who develop PANS attempt suicide. The rate of suicidal ideation for the illness, I believe it’s either fifty-eight or sixty-two percent. Many people say it’s higher. Fourteen percent of people with it attempt suicide. It is a dangerous illness that requires prompt and effective treatment.

Debbie:
Yeah. I feel like I’ve sighed more in this conversation than I probably ever have in a podcast interview. Like it’s, you’re the one on the ground doing this research and talking to people, and I know you have so much at stake in this. So I know why, but how do you navigate that just on a personal level, that kind of feeling, I imagine it’s like coming up against brick walls constantly and it’s so confounding to have there be such a mismatch between the evidence and the lived experience of people and then having this small group of people kind of deciding what’s going to happen.

Jessica Slice:
I mean, this has been an area in a year that has been beyond difficult personally. This has been a way that I feel like I can have some power and control. Like I’m really good at doing research and getting a bunch of information in and synthesizing it and being able to be good at something while watching my daughter suffer, which I guess is a weird way of phrasing that. But like I have felt so out of control. And knowing, this will make me weep, but knowing what she has endured, it has come very close to destroying me. And then being able to take part of myself and fight so hard on this makes me feel like I’m still alive. I also, you and I have talked a lot about privacy. And you know, I’ve talked to her a lot about sharing this. And this has really made me reconsider how I think about privacy because there are so many kids dying. And I think making her into a person and making our story into a narrative could save lives. And I now am starting to think like, is privacy the realm of the privileged? Do you get privacy when you don’t have to prove your personhood? When you see a kid starving or a kid in war, you don’t think about their privacy? You think, look, that’s a real person. We have to remember this is a real person. When you see immigration photos, you think, look, that’s a real child. We have to care about them. And I feel like we have shifted from a family where I’m so protective of privacy to look, we are real human, complete, complex people. And we are an example of all of these children who we have to fight harder for. And it’s anyway, it’s just really shifted the way I think about that.

Debbie:
Yeah. And you also talked to a lot of people who had PANS as kids or it’s still recurring. Like, you know, you mentioned flares. So can you talk about the people that you got to connect with in researching this piece about their lived experience? Because again, this is not a small number of people. It’s a very real thing. And there are adults who can explain what it’s like for them.

Jessica Slice:
So I’ve spoken to young adults who received prompt treatment as kids and experienced total remission and have not flared. I’ve also spoken to some who have repeated flares. There seems to be in research some correlation to how fast someone is diagnosed and treated and the long-term prognosis, like how likely they are to continue flaring. I’m resisting at this moment explaining the difference between the innate and adaptive immune system and how that shifts between an auto-inflammatory and autoimmune condition. But there seems to be some sort of shift in the mechanism of the disease with duration. So something really interesting is a lot of these young adults don’t remember the very worst times. And there are some parents who have donated their kids’ brains for kids who have died. And in those brains, they found Alzheimer’s like changes in the basal ganglia. So it seems to be that actually the ability to create memories during the very worst moments is impaired. And I feel like that’s a mercy. And I wish that for my daughter. I don’t know yet what she remembers. But there are people who get better. I spoke to Harold Perrineau, who was Mercutio in the Romeo and Juliet of our childhood, and he’s now in a show called From and he’s a great actor. His daughter had this, and she went a long time without getting diagnosed, and finally improved, I think around 11 and developed symptoms at three. And she doesn’t remember years and years of her life, but she’s doing well now. She’s attending Stanford starting soon. And she hopes to work at the clinic at Stanford, and intern there, you know, so she can help kids who went through what she went through. I mean, I’ve talked to a woman getting her PhD in Florida who had this as a child and is now studying so that she can treat other kids with this. So people do get better and they have a range of how close to their baseline they end up.

Debbie:
So I wonder if we could just spend a few minutes and we’ll start to wrap up. But because again, as I was researching this years ago, and I am not nearly as thorough a researcher as you are, but I definitely found that especially like a co-occurrence with autism, for example, that there are people who say that it’s not autism, it’s PANS PANDAS, and then there are people that it can be co-occurring. And so what did you find in your research in terms of the relationship, if there is a relationship between neurodivergence and PANS?

Jessica Slice:
A lot of researchers think it is slightly more likely in kids with autism. I don’t know if research will bear that out with additional studies, but that’s currently what they think. There are some people who are like, well once you treat this thoroughly, the autism goes away. I do not believe that’s the case. That’s my own personal opinion, but based on a decent amount of research, I think there’s a distinction. I have observed a real distinction between them. At first we wondered if this was burnout. But the neurological signs, like the way my daughter’s gait changed, the way she lost the ability to write, she lost the ability to throw a ball, her handwriting became like a two-year-old’s, there were just clear neurological signs. I think it can be maybe hard for a healthcare professional to say like this is clearly PANS versus this is clearly autism. But I think for a parent, there’s really no question. I was telling you, we had a good weekend for the first time in a year. And I left the house with my daughter, and she was still autistic. Like she still exclusively wanted to talk about Tomodachi Life. And like that, that is who she is. And she still felt close to her baseline from PANS. Like that to me, it was just obvious.

Debbie:
Yeah. Yeah. That makes absolute sense. We’ll start to wrap up. I reread the article in preparing for this conversation and I was like, I’m gonna check out the comments because I’m curious to hear what the feedback has been. And so I’m really curious from your perspective, you know, what is the reception to your kind of really sharing this incredible story and all the research that you did, putting it out into the world in a really high profile publication. What’s the response been?

Jessica Slice:
I have not read the comments yet. I tend to avoid comments. I have received hundreds, at this point maybe more than six hundred emails and DMs from people telling me their stories and thanking me for the piece. New York magazine told me it did very well. So a lot of people have read it. My hope is it can move the needle. My hope is it can serve to legitimize this when someone sees a change in their child and goes to their pediatrician. I’m hoping, like what I would hope is this would make a pediatrician willing to try antibiotics for a sudden onset psychiatric symptoms to see. Because if they help, they’ve learned something. I did, it didn’t make it into the piece, but I actually interviewed three infectious disease doctors to talk about is there a risk of antibiotic resistance if every child who develops sudden-onset psychiatric symptoms were to do a trial of azithromycin, and they all said no, it does not increase population-wide antibiotic resistance risk at these numbers. So, because that’s a common concern, you know, well, we don’t want to do too many, but I checked.

Debbie:
Okay, yeah, that’s a good question to ask. I love that you asked that. Yeah. Just to put the kibosh on that bit. Yeah.

Jessica Slice:
Yeah. And they all specialize in antibiotic resistance. So I really checked. Yeah. And I was gonna mention something that I found really interesting is that the rate of later autoimmune illness for kids who have PANS and PANDAS is quite high. And there are also, in my daughter when I look back, signs of early autoimmune illness. So I think we’ll learn a lot about how this really, you know, I think this is similar to Crohn’s and colitis or ulcerative colitis and juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, like any other childhood autoimmune illness. I think we’ll end up realizing this has a lot of overlaps, but that the place in the body that’s impacted is the brain. And so it feels more confusing than if it’s swollen joints.

Debbie:
Right. Yeah. I’m just gonna let you know that the comments were all good, just so you know. I read the comments for you. They were overwhelmingly messages of gratitude. My family’s been through this. And also there was a lot of support for other parents in the comments. Have you tried this? So it was a really generous comment thread. So just letting you know. Yeah.

Jessica Slice:
Okay, that’s lovely. Yeah, I tend to just, for my own, I’ve done enough things publicly that for my own mental health I like don’t go into comment sections.

Debbie:
I think that is a very fair policy, a thousand percent. So, as a last question for listeners who wonder, is this what’s going on? Because again, you know, some folks in my community have recently discovered that this is what’s happening with their child after so many different directions, right? Is there something that you learned that you would do differently or that you would advise people to kind of yeah, a direction to go in as soon as they suspect this could be going on.

Jessica Slice:
Couple of things. One, and there’s something really tricky here, but I just want to say it. It is very hard to access medical care for this. And as a result, because the universe abhors a vacuum, there are people who offer treatments and offer explanations and may sound a little too confident, like that’s kind of a way your spidey sense can pick it up, or may say they figured it all out. And those people are sometimes grifters. And I do not blame parents for pursuing treatments that aren’t evidence based because we are desperate. But I would really, even when it’s impossible, fight as hard as you can to pursue treatments that would be advised on the PANS PANDAS Physicians Network page. I think that’s a really good page. It is the page that doctors made for other doctors. And that’s why I go there. Generally, I guess that’s one thing I will say is when I’m trying to get information about something medically, I try to listen to doctors talking to other doctors. And maybe that’s outside of the capacity of people. I know that may feel like an obnoxious thing to say, but I think it’s a way of bypassing grifters, because people aren’t gonna grift two doctors in the same way. So I guess I just wanna say be careful. It’s a minefield, but be careful. The other thing I would say is to visit that page or other reliable, you know, you can go through Stanford or the Dartmouth Clinic. And then pursue the treatments that are recommended by the PANS Physicians Consortium. For us and for many, many people, the first steps are NSAIDs and antibiotics. And there’s a pretty good argument for antibiotics, which is what’s the harm? And you can make that argument to your doctor. They can also contact, you know, they can visit that same page and watch Grand Round Talks and read medical journal articles. That website has a collection of all the recent research and it’s really solid research. So that’s a way to introduce someone. If you have a physician that prefers to use AI, Open Evidence, you know, is a medical AI site. And if you type into Open Evidence, what is the mechanism of PANS and PANDAS, it will outline the recent research I have found in a very clear way. I know there are all sorts of complications with using AI, but I’m kind of keeping in mind accessibility. But the things that people say is it’s like they’ve become a different child, it’s like they’re possessed and then these kids jump out of cars, or they collect their spit. And if those things happen, then you just have to like, God, you just have to fight like hell.

Debbie:
So grateful for this conversation. Thank you. Like just for sharing your whole story with us and it’s just such a gift for so many families who are struggling right now. So thank you for the article, your Substack. Would you share with people where they can connect with your Substack and with you? Because it’s great.

Jessica Slice:
Thanks. So my website is jessicaslice.com and you can access, well I have a link right at the top and you can sign up for a mailing list where I’m keeping people updated on PANS advocacy and news. And then my Substack is jessicaslice.substack.com and that has now turned into a PANS Substack, against my will. And yeah.

Debbie:
Well, I mean, you’re also a gifted writer. So I think it’s, I’m sure this isn’t the area of special interest you necessarily wanted to go down, but you’re now using your talents and your gifts to, as you said, push the needle forward. So thank you. Thank you for doing what you do. And again, thanks for this conversation. It was such a pleasure.

Jessica Slice:
Yeah, thanks for having me here. And I’m just thinking about parents listening to this whose kids have gone through this and it’s so impossible, but you can believe what you’re seeing with your eyes.

THANKS SO MUCH FOR LISTENING!

Do you have an idea for an upcoming episode? Please share your idea in my Suggestion Box.